P42 Camouflage Jacket Comparision – Original vs Repro

Finally completed my P42 camo jacket comparison. Original P42 camouflage jackets are rare and very pricy. So they are no good for reenacting, airsofting and other outdoor activities. Hopefuly this short comparison will help you to choose a reproduction jacket. I picked the top three repros (At the Front, SM Wholesale, WWII Impressions) and compared them to an original jacket. There are cheaper alternatives from (mostly) Chinese eBay sellers and other manufacturers but those are of questionable quality when compared to the best repros and I chose not to include them in this comparison.

From left to right: SM Wholesale, WWII Impressions, Original, At the Front (click to enlarge)

Colour:

Even mint original P42 jackets exhibit colour differences, there is no “perfectly correct colour”. For this comparison i picked an original jacket that saw use and has mediocre fading. Colour wise the WWII Impressions green side & grown side colour is closest to the originals I have seen. ATF reproduction is good too, the base colour of the green side is quite “golden/yellowish”, while this will make many reenactors happy it is actually less common on originals then the greener shades. Be careful when washing ATF jackets they fade rather quickly (strangely the black colour of the EGA fades much slower then the rest). In contrast to this the WWII Impressions Jacket fades very slowly. SM Wholesales colour is a bit odd, these jackets were used in the Mini Series “The Pacific” and they come “pre aged”. It seems to achieve a used look they have not only been washed several times (looks cool!) but in addition they have been “tinted” in a yellowish colour. This is most apparent on the brown side which is too yellow.

Please not that my camera does not capture the colours too well, also the photos have been taken at different times of day. The “green side” photo with all jackets next to each other is probably closest to the real colours (of course that depends on your monitor too 😉 )

Cut:

Cut of all three repros is good, sizing of the WWII Impressions jacket is a bit on the small side, ATFs rather large.

Fabric:

All three repros are well made and of good quality, SM Wholesale uses the heaviest fabric. As you might know the weave of USMC HBT was different from Army HBT. All USMC camouflage was printed on Army style HBT though. ATF and SM Wholesale use the correct Army HBT, WWII Impression uses USMC style weave.

At the Front:

Original:

SM Wholesale:

WWII Impressions:

Breast pocket

SM Wholesale:

At the Front:

Original:

WWII Impressions:

Snaps

SM Wholesale:

At the front:

WWII Impressions:

Original:

Close-up of the lower pocket button

At the Front:

SM Wholesale:

Original:

WWII Impressions:

Hope this post will help you to make your choice when choosing a repro P42 jacket. If not for the wrong HBT weave my vote would probably go to the WWII Impressions reproduction. Check out my P41 comparison too.

~ by m1pencil on September 20, 2011.

6 Responses to “P42 Camouflage Jacket Comparision – Original vs Repro”

  1. I bought a set of ATF’s when they came out, did exactly what they told people not to do, threw them in the washer, then the dryer then out in the sun….Boy do they look great now !! I like everything except the shiny snaps on the coral side…

    Enjoy your blog, keep up the good work !!

    Buck Waddell
    Waveland, IN

  2. Very Nice to see the repro comparisons. I think it is very important to see how the “current” versions measure up to the originals.
    As part of my research and acquisitions work for HBO’s The Pacific series, another maker was brought in as additions to those made by SM Wholesale. I assigned the Taiwan maker, Supply Section to help us manufacturer camo shelter halves in addition to a limited number or sets of the P-42 camo outfits. Rigger made utility caps and helmet covers were also included.

    Please drop me a line, would love to hear from you,
    Monty Hom
    (co-founder , What Price Glory.)

  3. hi

    I’ve been looking to get this HBT fabric by the yard to make a few custom items from it. Do you happen to know where I can find that? Any help would be appreciated.

    Brian

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: